Hello dear
Welcome to Portside Pizza
Portside Pizza, located in Columbia City, IN, is a beloved local gem known for its exceptional pizza and inviting atmosphere. The standout dish, the Titanic Pizza, boasts an array of toppings, including generous portions of ham, mushrooms, crisp onions, and green peppers, all enveloped in an abundance of cheese. Customers rave about the quality and value of the food, with many describing it as the best pizza they've ever had. While service may sometimes be slower, the friendly staff and cozy setting make it a welcoming spot for pizza lovers. Portside Pizza is a must-try for anyone craving delicious slices in Northeast Indiana.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Crazy Dough
Bbq Chicken Pizza
Taco Pizza
Hawaiian
About
Portside Pizza
Welcome to Portside Pizza, a delightfully local gem nestled in the heart of Columbia City, Indiana. Located at 5310 N Old Indiana 102, this pizza haven boasts not only a convenient address but also a commitment to excellent food, exceptional value, and a cozy atmosphere that keeps patrons returning for more.
As you step inside Portside Pizza, you're greeted by a comforting vibe, an inviting setting ideal for families and friends. The aromas wafting through the air are enough to excite your taste buds and prepare you for what's to come. But the real star of the show? The pizza, of course!
Many locals rave about the Titanic Pizza, a standout dish that has garnered a cult following. With plentiful toppings ranging from fresh vegetables to generous amounts of cheese, it's a pizza that many reviews describe as unforgettable. One customer, Jeffery Long, exclaimed that the Titanic Pizza was "by far the best pizza that we had ever had," thanks to its vibrant toppings and perfectly balanced flavors. The combination of chunks of ham, mushrooms, crisp onions, and green peppers makes each bite a culinary delight.
While the food shines brightly at Portside Pizza, other aspects are also noteworthy. While a few guests mention that service can be slower than expected, the friendliness and attentiveness of the staff, like their wonderful waitress Tessa, certainly contribute to a warm dining experience. As Greg Eley noted, the food is "delicious AND great value," confirming that Portside Pizza is a place where you can enjoy high-quality meals without breaking the bank.
Accolades from customers like Nathan Turner, who humorously described his experience, and Jim Neuendorf, who appreciated the overall fine atmosphere, illustrate that Portside Pizza is more than just a meal; it’s an experience. Whether indulging in a Titanic roll or savoring a slice of their illustrious pizza, patrons are met with flavors that linger long after the meal is over.
If you're seeking a place to satisfy your pizza cravings, Portside Pizza stands ready to impress. With its excellent menu, welcoming staff, and a reputation for serving some of the best pizza in Northeast Indiana, it’s the perfect spot to enjoy food with friends and family. Don’t miss out on discovering your new favorite slice!
To get in touch or place an order, call +1 260-691-3333. Make Portside Pizza your next dining destination—you won’t regret it!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Good, local pizza place. Food is delicious AND great value! Titanic is one of the best deluxe pizzas in NE indiana. ”
“ Excellent pizza. Service ok but slower than expected. Atmosphere was fine. ”
“ The huzz took my order and recommended the Titanic Pizza. I ended up getting strapped to a wooden door panel and thrown in the deep freezer. They even had music playing for the ultimate experience. I would highly recommend this place to friends and family. ”
“ My wife and I tried Portside Pizza on 6/7/25. The pizza (thin crust Titanic) will forever haunt both of us! We both agreed that it was by far the best pizza that we had ever had. If you dream of the perfect pizza, this is it! Tons of toppings, with actual chunks of ham, mushrooms that could be in a salad bar, crisp onion,and green pepper, and an abundance of cheese. The price was right also. Our server was very nice as well. We will definitely be back! ”
“ Great place for some fantastic food and beer. We had the Titanic roll and it was amazing. More than big enough for two people with enough to take home for leftovers. Our waitress Tessa was the best. Very friendly and on top of everything. I highly recommend this place. ”
“ Best pizza in the area! The Titanic is amazing! Service is always quick and friendly. I do carry out everytime. Great the next day :) ”
“ Pizza was delicious, and the staff was friendly. We got the deep dish, and we will definitely return! ”
“ My 86 year old dad can't stop talking about how good his sausage roll was. Best he's ever had. Great food, great service, just a little cold in the dining room but it was freezing outside so understandable. ”